PROPOSITION
101
AN
INITIATIVE MEASURE
PROPOSING
AN AMENDMENT TO THE CONSTITUTION OF ARIZONA; AMENDING ARTICLE II OF
THE ARIZONA CONSTITUTION BY ADDING SECTION 36 OF ARTICLE II; RELATING
TO FREEDOM OF CHOICE IN HEALTH CARE.
Be it enacted by the
People of Arizona:
1. Article II, Section
36: Constitution of Arizona is proposed to be added as follows if approved
by the voters and on proclamation of the Governor:
ARTICLE
II, SECTION 36. BECAUSE ALL PEOPLE SHOULD HAVE THE RIGHT TO MAKE DECISIONS
ABOUT THEIR HEALTH CARE, NO LAW SHALL BE PASSED THAT RESTRICTS A PERSON'S
FREEDOM OF CHOICE OF PRIVATE HEALTH CARE SYSTEMS OR PRIVATE PLANS OF
ANY TYPE. NO LAW SHALL INTERFERE WITH A PERSON'S OR ENTITY'S RIGHT TO
PAY DIRECTLY FOR LAWFUL MEDICAL SERVICES, NOR SHALL ANY LAW IMPOSE A
PENALTY OR FINE, OF ANY TYPE, FOR CHOOSING TO OBTAIN OR DECLINE HEALTH
CARE COVERAGE OR FOR PARTICIPATION IN ANY PARTICULAR HEALTH CARE SYSTEM
OR PLAN.
2. The Secretary of
State shall submit this proposition to the voters at the next general election
as provided by Article XXI, of the Constitution of Arizona.
Proposition 101 would amend
the Arizona Constitution to provide that no law shall:
-
Restrict a person's
freedom to choose a private health care plan or system of their choice.
-
Interfere with a person's
or entity's right to pay directly for lawful medical services.
-
Impose a penalty or
fine, of any type, for choosing to obtain or decline health care coverage.
-
Impose a penalty or
fine, of any type, for participation in any particular health care system
or plan.
State law requires the Joint
Legislative Budget Committee (JLBC) Staff to prepare a summary of the fiscal
impact of certain ballot measures. Proposition 101 is not estimated to
have a state fiscal impact. The proposition may affect future operation
of the Arizona Health Care Cost Containment System (AHCCCS) and state employee
health benefits. The impact on these programs cannot be determined in advance.
As an orthopedic surgeon, there
is no greater satisfaction than seeing your patients get back to doing
what they like to do. Helping patients achieve their goals means honoring
their wishes to pursue the care that they believe is best.
The Freedom of Choice in Health
Care Act keeps patients in control of their health and health care.
The Freedom of Choice in Health
Care Act protects people from having their health care choices dictated
by government-appointed bureaucrats.
The Freedom of Choice in Health
Care Act preserves our rights to seek second opinions, choose alternative
care, and keep our medical records private.
The Freedom of Choice in Health
Care Act makes patient freedom the top priority in health care reform.
Do not let special interests
turn health care reform into another way of using taxpayer money to enrich
them at the expense of your health.
Join me in voting FOR protecting OUR
HEALTH CARE RIGHTS.
VOTE
YES ON PROPOSITION 101!
|
Eric Novack,
MD, Chairman, Medical Choice for Arizona, Glendale
|
|
Paid for
by "Medical Choice for Arizona"
|
ARGUMENT
IN FAVOR OF THE FREEDOM OF CHOICE IN HEALTH CARE ACT
On behalf of the Arizona
chapter of Americans for Prosperity (www.aztaxpayers.org), we encourage
all Arizona taxpayers and health care consumers to vote YES on Prop 101,
the Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act.
One of the hallmarks of the
American free enterprise system is freedom of choice. When consumers
are free to choose, the result is higher quality and lower prices. But
over the past 60 years, our national and state governments have increasingly
intervened in the health care marketplace, restricting consumer choice.
America still has the highest-quality health care in the world, but prices
have increased much faster than productivity in the medical sector. As
a result, many Americans find health insurance unaffordable. Others are
afraid to change jobs, because of their dependence on employer-provided
health insurance.
Our concern is that some
of the health care "reform" proposals put forth by special
interest groups (including some big insurance companies) attempt to reduce
costs by further restricting the choices of health care consumers. That
is the opposite of what Americans need. We should reduce costs by increasing
freedom of choice for health care consumers, and by making sure that
patients in need have the widest possible variety of medical options.
The Freedom of Choice in
Health Care Act will guarantee that the government cannot take away our
right to make our own health care choices. We urge you to vote YES on
Prop 101.
|
Chad Kirkpatrick,
Arizona Chairman, Americans for Prosperity, Phoenix
|
Tom Jenney,
Arizona Director, Americans for Prosperity, Phoenix
|
|
Paid
for by "Americans for Prosperity"
|
ARGUMENT
IN FAVOR OF THE FREEDOM OF CHOICE IN HEALTH CARE ACT
I have been a general surgeon
for 30 years now. In that time, I have seen miraculous advances in medical
technology and pharmaceuticals. There are conditions and diseases that,
when I began my medical practice, were considered untreatable, but today
we can actually cure.
Helping people deal with
pain, death, and fear has taught me how important it is for people to
have control over their own health care decisions. People need to know
all the options that exist for them--including non-traditional "alternative" options.
They need to know that they will always be able to exercise those options,
even if that means paying directly for some of them.
I may be a doctor, but I
am well aware that I will also someday be a patient. All of us may face
pain and serious illness, and certainly death one day. It's the great
equalizer.
That's why I am working to
pass Proposition 101, "The Freedom
of Choice in Health Care Act." I know, more than most that, our
health care system badly needs reform. But I have seen how other nations--and
now some of our own states--have passed reforms that restrict the ability
of people to choose or obtain the medicines, tests, doctors, health plans,
or treatments that they desire--even if they are willing to pay directly
for them. I don't want any reforms to have those consequences, however
unintended.
Proposition 101 says, "Reform,
but protect Choice." Vote YES on Prop. 101.
|
Jeffrey A.
Singer, MD, FACS, Treasurer, Medical Choice for Arizona, Phoenix
|
|
Paid
for by "Medical Choice for Arizona"
|
ARGUMENT
IN FAVOR OF "THE FREEDOM OF CHOICE IN HEALTH CARE ACT"
If my years in government
and business have taught me anything, they have taught that whenever
the political system tries to tackle a problem that involves billions
of dollars, the special interests come out of the woodwork to fight for
their piece of the pie. Oftentimes, well-intentioned attempts at reform
degenerate into a pork-pulling wrestling match.
As we head into the election
of 2008, health care reform is on the front burner. And it should be.
Our system, which offers the best health care in the world, has costs
that are out of control, and people are finding themselves priced out
of the market. But my biggest fear is that once the politicians sit down
with the special interests to fix the system, the only party not represented
at the table will be us patients.
The special interests will
be good at making sure their bottom line is protected--even if that means
patients' choices get restricted.
But if we patients lose control
over our health care decisions, one of our most precious freedoms, then
we will no longer be free. We will be hostages of the special interests
and their political friends.
"The Freedom of Choice
in Health Care Act" guarantees that, whatever health care reform
is eventually enacted, it can never trespass on our right to make our
own health care choices. That's why I urge you to vote YES on Prop. 101.
|
John R. Norton,
Former U.S. Deputy Secretary of Agriculture; CEO, J.R. Norton Company,
Phoenix
|
ARGUMENT
IN FAVOR OF PROPOSITION 101.
We Arizonans have the opportunity
of voting for Proposition 101 which will ensure that no matter what changes
occur to fix our health care delivery system or make it more affordable,
that our freedom to choose a plan, doctor or get second opinions will
be preserved. The last thing we want as patients is to be restricted
by government bureaucrats or lobbyists as to what procedures we can receive
especially for a lift threatening illness or condition.
Proposition 101 ensures that
we are free to choose in the future the kinds of treatments that we receive
and that we have control over our most personal decisions along with
the advice of our trusted physicians.
When our nation was founded,
Benjamin Rush, signer of the Declaration of Independence, fought to have
medical freedom protected in our Bill of Rights alongside our first amendment
right to freedom of speech and of the press. He thought it necessary
to make sure that the government could never decide or dictate your health
care in the ever evolving and changing world of medicine. Never has that
risk been greater than today.
By voting YES on Proposition
101, you are in control of your health care choices regardless of what
ever changes may be made in the future.
Please VOTE YES on Proposition
101! To protect yourself and your families ability to control your health
care destiny.
|
Lori Klein,
Executive Director, Medical Choice for Arizona, Anthem
|
|
Paid
for by "Medical Choice for Arizona"
|
ARGUMENT
IN FAVOR OF THE FREEDOM OF CHOICE IN HEALTH CARE ACT
As a neurosurgeon at the
Barrow Neurological Institute, I utilize the latest in cutting edge technology
to provide the best care to patients suffering from complex neurological
diseases, such as brain tumors and aneurysms.
As these new technologies
continue to arise, the costs of providing state-of-the-art medical care
rise as well. Increased health care costs make it harder and harder for
all of our residents to get health insurance. I worry that many Arizonans
cannot afford to purchase health insurance. Reforms are needed.
Many nations--and now many
of the states of OUR nation--have made attempts to deal with the problem
of the uninsured. But what frightens me is that in most--if not all--of
these instances, the reforms have resulted in restricting the ability
of patients to choose their own doctors; or to seek a new and innovative
form of therapy-or an alternative form of therapy; or to get a second
or third opinion; or to purchase the type of health insurance plan that
best suits their needs.
We must not let that happen
here in Arizona. We need reform, but we must preserve freedom of choice.
Each and every one of us
will be a patient one day.
We must retain the right
to make our own health care choices. The "Freedom of Choice in Health
Care Act" will guarantee, in our state Constitution, the preservation
of medical choice.
Please join me in voting
YES on Proposition 101.
|
Robert F. Spetzler,
M.D., FACS, Phoenix
|
Argument for Proposition 101
As an orthopaedic surgeon,
I have devoted most of my adult life to eliminating the pain and suffering
that patients immobilized by severe joint disease must endure. Many of
these patients have come to me from other countries, such as Canada,
where their health care systems make them wait months, and sometimes
years, to get the kind of surgical intervention that Americans expect
to receive in a timely manner.
I have witnessed firsthand
how government-managed health care systems can, and do, fail to provide
the care they claim to guarantee. I have seen patients come here from
other countries seeking medications, doctors, and treatments that they
are denied, by law, in their own countries.
The health care systems from
which these people flee were all designed with the best intentions. They
were created to obtain the most health care coverage for the most people;
however, the realities cannot be ignored. In an effort to deliver health
care that is cost-effective to the taxpayers, these systems have limited
options, choice, and quality care to the very people they were designed
to help.
When we reform our health
care system, I want to ensure that the right of all patients to make
their own health care choices is not violated. This includes the right
to directly purchase the type of care they want. If people lose control
over their own health care decisions, they lose control over their lives.
"The Freedom of Choice
in Health Care Act" guarantees in the Arizona Constitution, that
the right of all patients to make their own health care choices will
never be infringed. I urge you to vote YES on Proposition 101.
|
Anthony K.
Hedley, MD, FRCS; President, Arizona Institute for Bone & Joint
Disorders, Phoenix
|
ARGUMENT
FOR PROPOSITION 101
My years in practice in clinical
internal medicine in central Phoenix, treating diverse people from all
walks of life has taught me that there is no more personal or precious
right than the right to make your own decisions regarding your health
care. Whether we are dealing with a fatal disease like cancer or a painful,
disabling disease like arthritis, patients must be able to make their
own choices about the kinds of treatments, tests, and doctors they want
to see.
They must be free to choose
alternative methods of care--even if the bureaucratic establishment does
not recognize them. A central part to being a patient is deciding how,
why, and where you pay for your healthcare. It is time to constitutionally
protect patients from government and bureaucracies that may seek to take
away our inalienable rights as patients to choose the financial arrangements
of our own health care.
My recent service as President
of the Arizona Medical Association brought me face to face with politicians,
bureaucrats, and special interest groups, all of whom had their own ideas
about what kinds of health care options should be made available to patients.
Whether they were well-intentioned politicians, budget-conscious bureaucrats,
or profit-driven insurance companies, they all thought they knew better
than the patients did about health care decisions.
Ultimately, no right is more
fundamental than the right to life. And no life is free without the right
to make one's own health care decisions.
The "Freedom of Choice
in Health Care Act" will guarantee in the Arizona Constitution that
no legislation can ever take that right from us.
That's why I urge you to
vote YES on Proposition 101, "The Freedom of Choice in Health Care
Act."
|
M. Zuhdi Jasser,
MD, Past President, Arizona Medical Association, Phoenix
|
ARGUMENT
IN FAVOR OF "THE FREEDOM OF CHOICE IN HEALTH CARE ACT"
I have been a family physician
in rural Arizona for over 30 years. If there is one thing that I have
come to appreciate during that time, it is the value of choice and options
for patients seeking health care.
Rural areas of the state
are often lacking in many of the specialty and other health care services
that urban areas provide. In some parts of the state, patients sometimes
need to travel long distances or wait for lengthy periods to get essential
health care services.
Our health care system is
in need of reform. But when that reform occurs, I worry that special
interests and budgetary concerns might result in rural Arizonans holding
the short end of the stick.
I want to make sure that,
whatever type of health care reform is enacted, it isn't a reform that
takes away the peoples' right to choose what kind of doctor or service
they want--even if they are willing to pay for it directly. I want to
make sure people retain the right to choose whether or not they want
to participate in any particular health plan.
When the politicians at the
state capitol hammer out a health care reform package, I want to make
sure that the Arizona Constitution guarantees that the rights of the
people--urban OR rural--to make their own health care decisions, shall
not be infringed. "The Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act" places
that guarantee in the Arizona Constitution.
I urge you to vote YES on "The
Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act."
|
Mark Ivey Jr.,
MD, Past President, Arizona Medical Association, Payson
|
Chiropractors understand
the impact powerful special interests can have on a profession. Over
the years, lobbyists have attempted repeatedly to make it more and more
difficult for patients to have chiropractic care as an option for certain
health problems.
The opportunity to protect
the ability of patients to be in control of their health and health care
and to determine which approaches and treatments are the most appropriate
for them does not come along often.
The Freedom of Choice in
Health Care Act elevates people above bureaucrats and back room, closed-door
deals.
The Freedom of Choice in
Health Care Act will keep patients in control over their health.
Voting YES on PROPOSITION
101 means that the people of Arizona will continue to have the broadest
number of health care options available to them and their families.
The members of the Arizona
Chiropractic Society proudly endorse The Freedom of Choice in Health
Care Act as an effort to keep Arizonans healthy!
No one can predict when or
if they will be injured or sick. No one treatment works for everybody.
Having choices can mean the difference between persistent pain and restored
health. The best recipe to maximize health requires keeping patients
in control over their health and health care.
VOTE
YES ON THE FREEDOM OF CHOICE IN HEALTH CARE ACT!
VOTE
YES ON PROPOSITION 101
|
Alan M. Immerman,
DC, President and Executive Director, Arizona Chiropractic Society,
Phoenix
|
Jennifer Haggard,
DC, Vice-President, Arizona Chiropractic Society, Phoenix
|
|
Paid
for by "Arizona Chiropractic Society"
|
Our state and nation's health
care systems are at risk.
For 100 years, the Arizona
Dental Association and its members have been committed to advancing the
dental and oral health of the public through leadership, education, and
research. Our members are dedicated to providing preventive and restorative
dental and oral health care to everyone in Arizona,
tailored
to their individual needs and we wholeheartedly support The Freedom
of
Choice in Health Care Act.
Giving government complete
control over what care you can receive and when, is not the
solution. One system does not fit all. No single system should remove your personal
freedom to decide the direction and treatment for you and your family.
The Arizona Dental Association
believes that dental and oral health must begin with the protection of
your right to decide which treatment options are best for you and your
family.
The Freedom of Choice in
Health Care Act protects and serves patients, not dentists. It will protect
the freedom to choose which treatment best fits your needs, the ability
to seek out second opinions, the right to decide which dentist is best
for you and your children--basic rights that should never be negotiable.
A YES vote on the Initiative
is a vote for the protection of your rights.
The Arizona Dental Association,
representing 80% of all dentists in Arizona, is proud to encourage Arizonans
to VOTE YES to preserve patient choice; VOTE YES to limit lobbyists and
special interests; and VOTE YES to protect your RIGHTS.
Please vote YES on The Freedom
of Choice in Health Care Act.
|
Regina E. Cobb,
DDS, President, Arizona Dental Association, Scottsdale
|
Todd Hellwig,
DDS, Treasurer, Arizona Dental Association, Scottsdale
|
|
Paid
for by "Arizona Dental Association"
|
All people in Arizona will
have their health care rights protected by voting YES on The Freedom
of Choice in Health Care Act.
As an operating room nurse,
and now as a nurse practitioner, I see firsthand how important it is
for patients to be in charge of their health care. As a mother, I want
my daughter to continue to have as many choices as possible for her health
and health care.
No bureaucrat should be able
to prevent patients from seeking out the care they believe is best.
Proposition 101 means you
and I will always have more rights over our health than any special interest,
no matter how much money the special interest spends on lobbyists.
Campaign contributions should
not be allowed to determine the future of our health care system.
Protect ALL of OUR HEALTH
CARE RIGHTS.
Vote YES on Proposition 101.
Vote YES on The Freedom of
Choice in Health Care Act.
|
Daria Pacheco,
RN, MSN, FNP-RNFA, Nurse Practitioner, Phoenix
|
The Freedom of Choice in
Health Care Act will preserve and protect patients' rights, and as a
patient, I support the initiative.
A one-size-fits-all government
run health care plan will make no one happy exept special interest groups,
especially the insurance and pharmaceutical industries. These two industries
have far too much influence over our health already, and we are worse
for it.
In a survey of 79 oncologists
from McGill University Cancer Center, 64 said they themselves would not
consent to treatment with Cisplatin, a common chemotherapy drug, while
58 oncologists said they would reject all the current trials being carried
out by their establishment. Why? "The ineffectiveness of chemotherapy
and its unacceptable degree of toxicity." But cancer is big business.
Standard chemo and radiation will likely be Standard of Care for another
50 years, despite the better alternatives out there. Why? The influence
of drug companies upon medical school curriculums and doctor education
programs.
In a one-size-fits-all government
run health care world, we would not be able to choose other alternative
methods. Even if we wanted to pay out of pocket for something else, we
would not be able to. We would be told exactly what we can do, and what
we cannot. My health is a very, very, personal matter. You bet I want
to have something to say about it.
Too many special interest
groups find it profitable when people are sick. A health care system
in the hands of bureaucrats and special interests will put someone else's
profitability above my health. There is too much pressure upon elected
officials to funnel our health care dollars into the pockets of special
interest groups. Our basic right to choose is coming under attack and
must be protected in the state constitution.
All Arizonans should support
the proposed amendment to the state constitution entitled, The Freedom
of Choice in Health Care Act.
We need to make certain that,
whatever legislation ultimately is approved by the Arizona Legislature
or voters, any unintended consequences of such legislation do not impact
on the people's right to make their own health care choices and decisions.
Given the growing political clout of those who stand to profit enormously
by certain health care schemes, our fundamental medical rights need to
be protected within the Arizona Constitution.
Without constitutional protection,
future "reforms" will be shaped by lobbyists, not by patients.
Those with disabilities know
that government-run health care will limit their ability to seek out
and obtain specialized care and treatments. People who want naturopathic
and homeopathic treatments know that government-run health care will
limit their ability to obtain it.
Who will lose if this amendment
passes? Those individuals and groups who believe that a government-run
health care system, controlled by bureaucrats and special interests is
the best kind of health care system reform.
The initiative will limit
the power of special interest groups to engage in `back room' or `closed
door' negotiations to get laws and regulations passed that claim to be
for the benefit of all people, when in fact the laws and regulations
first and foremost protect the interests of those who have the money
and power to lobby most effectively.
This initiative is a non-partisan
effort to preserve our individual autonomy and freedom regarding our
medical rights.
Letter in SUPPORT of The Freedom
of Choice in Health Care Act
Never should some unaccountable
bureaucrat be able to control what health care options are available.
I am a physician assistant,
and work alongside and under the supervision of physicians. Physician
assistants play an invaluable role in making health care more available,
more efficient, and safer for the people of Arizona.
The people of Arizona that
I am privileged to help take care value their choices. Most everyone
understands that, while our health care system has real problems, the
solution should not involve the sacrifice of giving up personal control
over their health and health care.
That is why The Freedom of
Choice in Health Care Act is so important to SUPPORT!
Vote YES on Proposition 101.
Physician Assistants (PAs)
and all Arizonans should vote YES on The Freedom of Choice in Health
Care Act!
|
Michelle Hitchcock,
Physician Assistant, Surprise
|
RE: The
Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act
I submitted 7000 petitions
to the Arizona Legislature last November signed by patients and doctors
in support of SB 1123 and SB 1236 who want unrestricted freedom of choice
in healthcare.
We are well aware special
interest groups wish to limit healthcare choices to a system which benefits
those groups. To place the decision-making capacity for our healthcare
in the hands of a government agency will further limit our choices, and
further increase our dissatisfaction with "the system." Bureaucrats
have no business making personal medical decisions for us.
Proposals abound that would
worsen the situation by giving control to entities more interested in
getting paid than giving good care. And the ugly issue of denying care
to particular patients with specific problems - looms large.
Increasingly, consumers are
rejecting the standard paradigm where you get a 10 minute office visit
with someone on the "approved" providers list and walk out
with a prescription while the assistant hollers, Next!" to a crowded
waiting room.
Consumers are looking for
better answers. More than 50 percent have stepped "out of the box" and
partaken of Complementary and Alternative medicine. Often, consumers
must pay out of their pockets for these treatments. They do so because
they do not want to simply manage their disease, which is primarily what
the conventional Standard of Care offers.
Attempts to put complete
control over all health care delivery into the hands of an appointed
bureaucracy means we will not even be able to pay out of own pockets
if we wish to. Someone wants to draw a very tight noose around our necks.
What a contemptuous lack of regard for we, the people.
We want better medicine,
better health care, and that means letting the free market operate.
Now more than ever, we need
to address the issue of covering the thousands of uninsured Arizonans.
However, real change cannot be in haste. In order to find success we
must first build a foundation for reform.
The Freedom of Choice in
Health Care Act will create a constitutional amendment that lays the
groundwork that will eventually help to effectively address this state's
health care crisis. It is imperative that we enable our more than 6 million
Arizona citizens to not be forced into a government regulated health
care system, but rather provide them with the true, free and unencumbered
choice of their own medical futures. In addition, this initiative will
not hinder the efforts our government has already established through
the AHCCCS program or Kids Care.
The Arizona Restaurant Association,
the second largest trade organization in the state, representing one
of Arizona's largest business communities and more than a quarter million
employees, supports this measure and encourages the support of Arizona
voters.
The Freedom of Choice in
Health Care Act is key to preserving Arizona's medical rights.
|
Steve Chucri,
President & CEO, Arizona Restaurant Association, Phoenix
|
Pat Connors,
Treasurer, Arizona Restaurant Association, Phoenix
|
|
Paid
for by "Arizona Restaurant Assocation"
|
ARGUMENT
IN FAVOR OF THE FREEDOM OF CHOICE IN HEALTH CARE ACT
I am a medical doctor specializing
in endocrinology. I focus a great deal of my practice on the diagnosis
and treatment of diabetes.
Before I entered private
practice, I was a physician in the military. I had the opportunity to
see what the practice of medicine is like in a world in which options
and choices are controlled and limited--where budgets, bureaucracy, and
politics decide the treatments, tests, and medicines available to the
patient.
In the civilian world, people
are free to set their own priorities and make their own choices. They
can weigh the risks and benefits for themselves. They are free to decide
if they want to try a new drug, a new test, or an alternative form of
treatment.
I worry that, as our political
leaders tackle the complicated issue of health care reform, special interest
politics may lead to patients losing control over their own health care
choices.
In the area of diabetes management,
new drugs, tests, and even surgeries continue to be developed at a breathtaking
pace. I don't want to see the day come when some bureaucrat, motivated
by budgets and politics, is the one who decides whether a person with
diabetes will be able to try a new drug or procedure. That decision should
always rest with the patient.
That's why I'm supporting "The
Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act." I want the right of the people
to make their own health care choices to be guaranteed by the Arizona
Constitution.
I urge you to vote YES on
Prop. 101, "The Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act."
|
Richard O.
Dolinar, MD, Clinical Endocrinologist, Glendale
|
ARGUMENT
IN FAVOR OF PROPOSITION 101
I spent two years in a wheelchair
and listened to several doctors express doubts I would ever walk again
or be without an oxygen tank. However, thanks to the most dynamic medical
system yet known to man, fabulous doctors, new drugs, and seven surgeries,
I can walk and breathe normally and be a mother to my two children. Stories
similar to mine are shared by millions of others.
What saved my life and theirs
was medical CHOICE. If one doctor said it was hopeless, I was free to
seek other help and opinions. Nobody said it just isn't cost effective
to fix you!
Having lived the first 25
years of my life as a military dependent, I have a quarter century of
experience with a government-run healthcare system. My health depended
on the convenience of the system.
Let's not let this happen
in America and especially right here in Arizona. We need to empower PATIENTS,
not faceless insurance companies or government clerks. We need to strengthen
the individual's right to choose the health care they need and the doctor
they prefer.
"The Freedom of Choice
in Health Care Act" makes health care choice a fundamental a right
in Arizona. And just as importantly this measure does not infringe on
the interests others may have to further expand health care for lower
income individuals or children. It simply ensures that when it comes
to health care, none of us will lose because we'll be able to choose
. . . our doctor, our specialist, and the care we need to get better.
Vote YES on Proposition 101, "The
Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act."
|
Randy Kendrick,
Paradise Valley
|
The Arizona Osteopathic Medical
Association (AOMA), representing 1,500 osteopathic physicians (D.O.s),
supports access to quality health care for Arizonans. Serving patients
for their healthcare needs is a top priority. It is important that patients
and their families be responsible and in control of their health care.
Our health care delivery "system" faces
an uncertain future. The Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act will help
maintain a wide array of health care treatment choices available and
accessible to Arizonans now and into the future. More importantly, the
Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act will protect the health care rights
of all Arizonans
The Arizona Osteopathic Medical
Association and its members ask that you join with us and VOTE YES on
this Proposition which will support the Freedom of Choice in Health Care
Act.
Thank you.
|
Charles A.
Finch, D.O., FACOEP, President, Arizona Osteopathic Medical Association,
Phoenix
|
Amanda L. Weaver,
MBA, Executive Director and Officer, Arizona Osteopathic Medical
Association, Phoenix
|
|
Paid
for by "Arizona Osteopathic Medical Association"
|
An Open Letter to Concerned
Citizens:
The mission of The Arizona
Homeopathic and Integrative Medical Association includes the need defend
the freedoms and abilities of our member physicians to practice medicine
in the best interests of the patient. This often includes grass roots
political action and a medical model (approach) that encourages and enhances
the body's own healing powers, maximizes your healing potential with
proper diet and the use of natural substances like vitamins and minerals.
Through these procedures
and techniques, thousands of Arizonans have seen their health improve
and their quality of life enhanced.
The very ability of people
to have access to the expertise of homeopathic and integrative practitioners
is at risk. Some other groups and lobbying groups
would like to make it harder, not easier, for patients to make homeopathic
and integrative care one of their health care choices.
We believe that health care
options that have been shown to make people better must be allowed and
not get legislated out of existence just to protect and appease certain
special interests.
We believe, The Freedom of
Choice in Health Care Act protects the rights of patients to choose,
not just homeopathic care, but a wide array of health care approaches
and modalities.
No bureaucrat should be able
to prevent you from making your own decision regarding the best health
care for you and your family.
Proposition 101, The Freedom
of Choice in Health Care Act, will PRESERVE and PROTECT YOUR HEALTH CARE
RIGHTS.
VOTE YES ON PROPOSITION 101.
|
Bruce Shelton,
MD, MD(H), DiHom, FBIH, President, Arizona Homeopathic & Integrative
Medical Association
|
Linda Wright,
MD, MD(H), Secretary/Treasurer, Arizona Homeopathic & Integrative
Medical Association
|
|
Paid
for by "Arizona Homeopathic & Integrative Medical Association"
|
As a nurse, caring for people
means understanding their needs, their desires, and the specifics of
their medical condition.
To provide the best care
requires working with patients to see that they remain in control over
their health and health care.
Health care reform should
take into account the ability of patients to make their own choices first.
The Freedom of Choice in
Health Care act will protect and preserve the right of people to be in
charge over their health and health care.
I have been a nurse for over
37 years--my patients will not be better off if government appointed
bureaucrats control health care.
That is why The Freedom of
Choice in Health Care Act must be placed alongside the other freedoms
we hold dear in the Arizona Constitution.
Join with me and vote YES
for health care freedom.
Vote YES for keeping patients
in charge over their health.
Vote YES for The Freedom
of Choice in Health Care Act.
Vote YES on Proposition 101.
|
Terri Aldama,
Registered Nurse, Clinical Nurse Educator, Banner Thunderbird Hospital,
Glendale
|
ARGUMENT
IN FAVOR OF "FREEDOM OF CHOICE IN HEALTHCARE ACT"
I have been a surgical nurse
for over 30 years. In that time, I have seen how important it is for
people to have control over their own health care decisions.
Whether we are talking about
new forms of medical treatment, new surgical devices, or alternative
forms of health care, we must respect the right of patients to be able
to seek out, learn about, and choose what they decide is right for them.
I am concerned that, as our
legislators attempt to bring needed reforms to our health care system,
the various special interests--insurance companies, employer groups,
political lobbyists--will influence the process in a way that will limit
patients' rights to choose their own health care and health plan. We
cannot let the financial interests of these lobbyist groups come ahead
of the interests of patients.
The
Freedom
of Choice in Health Care Act
guarantees--in the Arizona Constitution--that
we the people will always have the right to choose what kind of doctor
we want to see, what kind of therapy we want to try, what kinds of
medicines or surgical devices we want to obtain, and what kind of health
plans we agree to participate in.
We must guarantee
free
to choose
health care.
I strongly urge you to join
me in voting YES on the
Freedom
of Choice in Health Care Act.
|
Joyce McClain,
RN, CNOR, RNFA, BSHCM, Surgical Nurse, Phoenix
|
Is this an important initiative?
You can bet your life on it! Medical Choice for Arizona has devised a
guarantee that patient choice will always be permitted.
Your body is not a Toyota.
There are no standard practices that apply to everyone's heart problem,
multiple fracture or constant headache. The government cannot and should
not be the great arbiter of what your physician prescribes as treatment
or medication for you. Even if you and your neighbor are both diagnosed
with the same condition, many factors contribute to the best treatment
for each of you, unlike the book of standards to repair a transmission
in an old Ford or a new Honda. Health care is personal and individual.
Your government can't design a program to fit your needs. Sadly we've
come to a time when we have to take legal action to guarantee that you
will always have a choice.
Do you really want a nameless,
faceless and blameless government employee dictating what treatment or
prescription you and your doctor decide is right for you? Do you want
to wait for months to see a specialist for your heart condition when
your file is lost in some giant "Medical Supervision" office?
Reforms are necessary in
the health care field; however, taking away your choice is the most horrible
approach. Government doesn't have the right to give you a choice, you
already have that right. Government can only take away your choices.
We now have to ensure against that.
You can bet your life this
is an important initiative. I hope you will choose to vote YES and guarantee
that you will always have a choice.
|
Joyce E. Downey,
Scottsdale
|
I am a supporter of the Freedom
of Choice Act.
I believe it is my right
as a citizen of the United States of America to be able to choose and
be an active scriber and decision maker to the health care of my choice.
No law should be passed that restricts my ability to choose and be an
active decision maker in my healthcare choices regarding insurance plans
and healthcare systems of my choice. I also believe no law should be
passed that would charge penalties and fines to make healthcare decisions
on my own for the well being of myself and my family.
Thank you,
|
Stacy Stoffel,
Scottsdale
|
No right is more precious
than the right to be in control of your own health and health care.
I never want to contemplate
a time when me or my family will wake up in the morning and have to hope
that we can lobby a bunch of bureaucrats to get health care.
I know we have huge health
care system problems, especially the unbelievable cost.
But I do not want to think
that some group of `experts' will be able say that my life, my health
issues are not "important enough", and that the "greater
good" means that me, or my husband, or my children, or grandchildren
are "not worth" treating.
That is why The Freedom of
Choice in Health Care Act is so incredibly important to support.
I urge you to VOTE YES on
PROPOSITION 101.
None of us should let bureaucrats
have the chance to run our health and our lives---because they will run
us right into the ground.
SUPPORT THE FREEDOM OF CHOICE
IN HEALTH CARE ACT!
VOTE YES to keep people in
charge of their health.
The government can, does
and will help the most unfortunate among us.
Proposition 101 protects
them, protects me and my loved ones, and will protect all Arizonans from
government bureaucrats that misunderstand my compassion as a license
to control my health and health care.
VOTE YES on Proposition 101.
|
Barbara Brandt,
R.N., Surprise
|
I support the Arizona Freedom
of Choice Act. I do not now or at any time wish to have laws passed that
restrict my freedom to choose a private health care plan of any type.
I believe all citizens should have the right to make informed decisions
about their health care. I do not believe I should be declined the right
to pay for the healthcare of my choice, if this is my choice. I want
to continue to be an active decision maker in regards to my doctors,
hospitals, and healthcare coverage.
Thank you,
I grew up in England, but
have lived the past 30 years in the United States. I am a surgical technician,
and have worked with dozens of surgeons over these many years.
I can tell you with certainty
that, in spite of our health care system problems, we must take the steps
we need to ensure that health care freedom is protected here in Arizona.
I
SUPPORT THE FREEDOM OF CHOICE IN HEALTH CARE ACT.
We do not want a government-controlled
system where access to even the simplest medical care - that we take
for granted today in this country - is placed in the hands of bureaucrats
who really have no direct connection or responsibility for any individual
patient.
We must protect the right
to seek second opinions and explore every possible alternative for care.
We must VOTE YES on Proposition
101.
Letter in Support of The Freedom
of Choice in Health Care Act
As a mother of five, I have
had many chances to interact with doctors and nurses and other health
care professionals as both a parent and as a patient. I have also worked
in health care in nursing homes, physician offices, and hospitals for
over 25 years.
I see the problems in our
health care system first hand from many different perspectives.
And I know that unless we
preserve and protect my rights to be remain in control over my health
care and that of my children, the bureaucratic nightmares involved in
getting care will expand beyond imagination.
It is vitally important that
all Arizonans realize that a YES vote on Proposition 101 is a vote for
freedom.
A YES vote on Proposition
101 will keep government bureaucrats from taking over our health and
health care system.
I want all health care options
to be available for everyone in my family and for those options to be
protected forever.
VOTE
YES ON THE FREEDOM OF CHOICE IN HEALTH CARE ACT!
|
Rebecca Helems,
Registered Medical Assistant, Yuma
|
Letter in Support of The Freedom
of Choice in Health Care Act
I talk to patients every
day in my job as a certified nursing assistant. I believe patients must
be the ones to have the choices and control over their health and health
care.
I am a mother and grandmother.
I want my children and grandchildren to have every possible option for
health care available to them.
I want traditional and alternative
care, I want prescription medications, supplements, and natural methods
to not be restricted by some government appointed `experts' and bureaucrats
that care more about their lobbyist buddies than me, my family and my
patients.
That is why I am voting YES
on The Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act.
That is why all Arizonans
should vote YES on Proposition 101.
Keep special interests away
from my health care choices.
VOTE YES ON PROPOSITION 101.
|
Laureen Vines,
Certified Nursing Assistant, Mesa
|
Letter in Support of The Freedom
of Choice in Health Care Act
I am a native of Great Britain
who is a proud naturalized American citizen. I have lived and seen firsthand
how a government bureaucracy is not capable of providing individualized,
compassionate, patient- driven health care.
Much of my family and many
friends are still in England, living under the rules of a failing health
care system. And while we certainly have problems in this country with
cost and access, the options and availability of choices in health care,
including the latest life-saving technologies, are far better in Arizona
and the United States than in England.
We mustn't let slick partisans
peddle their government snake oil cure to our health care woes.
We must stand up and take
the steps to protect our rights first, before the lobbyists can take
over.
We must vote YES and SUPPORT
Proposition 101.
We must protect our health
and health care rights!
When I stood and took and
oath of allegiance to this great nation, I made a pledge to support the
ideals that make America great.
That is why I urge you to
VOTE YES on The Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act!
Letter in SUPPORT of The Freedom
of Choice in Health Care Act
My father was a cardiologist.
I have been a radiology technologist
for 44 years.
How medicine has changed.
My father would be simply amazed at the remarkable array of medications,
imaging techniques, therapies, treatments, and surgeries that have become
available since he passed away in 1972--health care choices that now
routinely save, prolong, and improve lives.
No doubt he would share my
horror that the gross intrusion of an uncaring and uninformed bureaucracy
that cares mostly about special interests and lobbyists.
I have lived my whole life
in health care, from the eyes of a child, to a proud professional, to
a patient, to a devoted care-giver.
I want my health care rights
protected.
I am voting YES on PROPOSTION
101.
VOTE YES ON THE FREEDOM OF
CHOICE IN HEALTH CARE ACT!
|
Jaquelyn P.
Costa, Registered Radiology and Mammography Technologist, Surprise
|
I am a supporter of the Freedom
of Choice Act.
As a small business owner,
I am a firm believer in having the ability to choose my own healthcare,
as it fits my needs, but also be able to tailor healthcare options to
the needs of my employees.
As a Husband and Father,
my family's well being must always come first when it comes to their
health and subsequent care. In the last year, my daughter has spent 6
months in a pediatric hospital, in which we had a choice as to which
one was best suited, got several opinions, not to excess and eventually
was able to diagnose and treat her appropriately. We have also chosen
to utilize Alternative medicine in the treatment of most common sickness
and other minor medical issues, as the answer isn't always in a pill.
All of these options are
important to me and my family. Thankfully, we live in a country/state
that still affords us these options. I do not believe any law or lawmaker
or lobbyist should interfere with a right that is so personal, as ones
healthcare.
Sincerely,
I am one of the 330,000 Arizona
citizens who signed the petition for the Freedom of Choice in Health
Care Act as I believe in the merits of this act.
As I owner of a small business,
I am a firm believer in providing my employees with full health care
coverage and for them to have the ability to choose their providers of
this health care. The relationship between a patient and their provider
is a very special one, and as such, patients need to have the ability
to choose with whom they want to develop this relationship.
We live in an incredible
country and there are endless benefits to being an American citizen.
One such freedom is the ability to make our own, personal choices for
healthcare coverage. I do not believe that any law or law maker should
interfere with this freedom. This is why I support the Freedom of Choice
in Health Care Act.
Sincerely,
I value the freedoms granted
and protected in our state and country. Nowhere else in the world does
opportunity and possibility offer so much for so many.
And that is why I am SUPPORTING
The Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act!
As a nurse with many years
of experience, I work hard to see to it that my patients remain in control
of their health and health care. I do not want to see government bureaucrats
take over that control.
Many choices for health care
exist, and some work better for certain people than others. It can be
a real challenge to balance health conditions, patient and family desires,
and available treatment options. What is right for my family and me may
not be right for yours.
The Freedom of Choice in
Health Care Act PROTECTS the health care rights of ALL Arizonans.
VOTE YES on Proposition 101.
Prompt, efficient, appropriate
and safe health care. That is the kind of care I pride myself in being
a part of during my 27 years as an operative room nurse.
The Freedom of Choice in
Health Care Act will help protect the ability of me and my colleagues
to continue to provide that kind of care.
As a patient, I want to continue
to be in control of my health care and to keep all of my options open.
The Freedom of Choice in
Health Care Act will preserve my right to be in control of my health
care.
I support PROPOSITION 101.
I urge you to VOTE YES on
THE FREEDOM OF CHOICE IN HEALTH CARE ACT.
As a practicing non physician
surgical assistant, I recognize the fundamental need for patients to
have their right to be in control of their health and health care choices.
I work with surgeons through
out the greater Phoenix metropolitan area. I understand that having the
right physician performing the right operation, at the right time, requires
more than just empty government and bureaucrat promises. As a provider
of medical services that is involved in essential support services to
doctors, nurses and hospitals on behalf of the surgical patient, I am
acutely aware of the impact of seemingly arbitrary and random rules and
regulations.
The Freedom of Choice in
Health Care Act will preserve and protect patients' rights, and I wholeheartedly
support the Initiative.
My craft involves helping
patients get their surgeries performed safely and efficiently. I strongly
believe that keeping control of health care decisions in the hands of
patients and families, and out of the hands of special interests who
are more interested in getting paid than the care given to particular
patients with specific problems, is essential on the issue of patients'
rights.
I encourage all Arizonans
to vote YES to protect health care freedom.
I want all Arizonans to vote
YES to keep control over health care out of the hands of bureaucrats
and special interests.
I want all Arizonans to vote
YES on Prop 101, The Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act.
|
Eugene O. Smith,
B.S., C.S.A., Phoenix
|
I am concerned Arizona is
the focus of efforts that will be described as "the solution to
universal health care" but are really about creating a government-run
health care system that will not be accountable to patients, the consumer.
A government-run health care
plan will be shaped in great part by special interest groups who generously
fund political campaigns. The end result would hijack everyone's right
to make their own choices in healthcare in an effort to force the flow
of patients' dollars to special interest groups.
Patients are resisting the
domination of medicine by the pharmaceutical and insurance industries.
Many doctors are resisting an industrial "one size fits all" approach
to human health. Increasingly, patients and doctors want a wider range
of choices in health care.
The creation of HMOs and
PPOs gave insurance companies more control. If I asked for applause from
those who like how that turned out, the silence would be deafening. Shall
we take it three steps further? No.
It simply is in the best
interest of good healthcare not to put control over all health care delivery
in the hands of an appointed bureaucracy.
A variety of health care
treatment alternatives exist and the public should be able to partake
freely of those opportunities. We should not be forced into a government
created plan about which we have no meaningful input, no control, no
redress.
I support the Freedom of
Choice in Health Care Act as an initiative for the November 2008 ballot
in Arizona. It will protect my right to make my own health care choices.
Our healthcare system has
problems, but FREEDOM has NEVER been one of them!
Prop 101 protects your rights
as consumers to have the freedom to choose your own doctor, hospital,
health plan, treatment, etc.
Some politicians are pushing
a government takeover as the only solution to our healthcare problems.
They think they know better than you. They want to socialize medicine;
they want a "single payer" system.
Do
you really want the same type of government bureaucrat who ran FEMA during
Hurricane Katrina to dictate your doctor, your health plan, and your
treatment?
When I get bad service at
a restaurant or store, I have the freedom to go down the street to their
competitor. If they provide bad service, I can change again; no government
permission required.
Every year, I get a physical.
The lab facility closest to my home always has a long wait, so I pay
a little more and drive down the street to a location without waiting.
Others may prefer a location that is cheaper or closer to home, and are
willing to wait. Competition and the freedom to choose allow both of
us to be satisfied.
There are many reasons to
want the freedom to choose your own doctor. Choosing a doctor is a very
personal decision. Each person values location, education, experience,
and just plain old "bedside manner" differently. You should
not have to get permission from a government bureaucrat to change doctors
for any reason; it should remain a personal decision.
This initiative does not
prevent the government from fixing our healthcare problems.
It
just says that whatever they do, they cannot take away your right to
choose your own doctor, hospital, health plan, or treatment.
Freedom
works!
That's
why I am voting YES on Prop 101.
|
Dean Martin,
State Treasurer, Phoenix
|
Argument
Against "Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act"
The Arizona Coalition for a
State and National Health Plan opposes the "Freedom of Choice in Health
Care Act" initiative to amend the Arizona Constitution.
1. An Amendment limiting future
legislation is dangerous. No one can predict what laws may be needed to
improve the health of Arizonans.
2. The Amendment will NOT assure
one's freedom to choose a personal physician, but will prevent the state
from creating a system assuring everyone access to the care they require.
This amendment will require private alternatives that may not be universal,
would limit services, and exclude individuals with preconditions. This
is not "choice," it is a mandate for restrictions.
3. Arizonans who now rely on
Medicare or Medicaid could lose coverage. Private alternatives would have
to be created to satisfy the amendment, but coverage of the elderly or
the poor is not profitable. With no alternatives, Medicare and Medicaid
could be lost.
4. The Proposition's goal,
to
prevent abuses associated with "socialized" medicine
, is irrational. The only "socialized" medical programs in the
US are the Veterans Health System, the Indian Health Service, and military
medical services. None abuse the private sector. Socialized systems are
funded by the Government. They provide services in government facilities
by professionals who work for the U.S. Public Health Service. No one
is abused by "socialized medicine" in America.
5. Passage of a Constitutional
Amendment in Arizona would limit legislative options. It will increase
the abuses that private practitioners, hospitals, and patients now suffer
from private insurance carriers. The industry dictates reimbursement, determines
the services patients receive, and dictates who shall be granted or denied
access to care.
|
Jonathan B. Weisbuch,
MD, MPH, FACPM, Chair, Arizona Coalition for a State and National
Health Plan, Phoenix
|
Mary Ellen Bradshaw,
MD, Co-Chair, Arizona Coalition for a State and National Health Plan,
Phoenix
|
|
Paid for
by "Jonathan Weisbuch"
|
ARGUMENT AGAINST C-15-2008:
Vote NO!
The health care system in
the United States is seriously flawed, causing people to be maimed, and
according to the U.S. Academy of Science causing at least 18,000 to die
each year because they lack health care insurance.
This proposal wants the citizens
of Arizona to be prevented from being able to obtain `universal health
care' for all.
In the spring of 2008, Frontline,
the Public Broadcasting System show, surveyed the `universal health care'
systems of five industrial nations (i.e., Japan, Great Britain, Switzerland,
Taiwan, and Germany) in order to compare them to the fragmented health
care system in the United States.
The largest economy in the
world (i.e., United States) ranks 25th, 30th, 35th, etc. for various
medical morbidity and mortality statistics compared to Japan (the number
two economy) with Japan's health statistics always in the top ten.
Yet, the U.S. has the most
expensive health care system by far. The U.S. per capita health care
costs twice as much as Japan. The U.S. squanders 16% of our Gross Domestic
Product for health care compared to Japan's 8%. In addition, only 6.5%
of the health cost in Japan is for administration compared to the U.S.'s
21.5%. No health care - - just paperwork and profits while people are
crippled or die.
All five countries surveyed
contained three key elements: (1) all citizens must have health insurance
- whether private or governmental was irrelevant, (2) no citizen may
be denied coverage because of pre-existing conditions, and (3) the insurance
companies can not make a profit.
This proposal prevents "Health
care coverage for all in Arizona while allowing persons without insurance
to die".
Vote NO!
|
Bradley K.
Vandermark, Phoenix
|
We at Healthy Arizona have
demonstrated our ability to put before you initiatives that made sense
and brought health care to literally hundreds of thousands of hard-working,
low income Arizona families. You've voted, overwhelmingly, twice, for
what we've put on the ballot, because you recognized that we are on your
side, have no special interests to placate, and share your values. We
are now asking you to vote NO on Prop 101, because it is a really bad
idea.
"The Freedom of Choice
in Health Care Act" purports to offer more "choice" of
health insurance to Arizonans, when, in fact, it would prevent us from
being able to choose from a number of options that are available, and
are being tried and proven elsewhere. Why would anyone propose that we
close the door before we know what works and what doesn't?
There are now over 1 million
Arizonans without health insurance-- 1/5 of our state population. This
affects us all, by raising health costs for untreated illnesses, at the
time when treatment is the most effective, and least expensive. The problem
is getting worse, as insurance rates soar. This cannot go on. Let's leave
our options open, to borrow approaches used by other states, and even
other countries, to hold down costs and improve access to care!
Vote NO on Prop 101!
|
Eve Shapiro,
MD, MPH, Chair, Health Arizona, Tucson
|
|
Paid
for by "Healthy Arizona"
|
"Church Women United
urges a NO vote.
This initiative has the deceptive
appearance of giving you more choices, but, really, it is about limiting
our choices. We all know that this state is in a crisis about folks not
being able to get health insurance, and about individuals being thrown
off their plans, and businesses no longer being able to offer insurance.
Half the people in bankruptcy are there because of healthcare costs,
and a lot of them had insurance that they had paid into, for years, but
the coverage got smaller and the premiums larger, and the bills came
in.
The only "choice" a
lot of folks have, increasingly, is to have no insurance, or less-than-adequare
insurance, and to hope and pray for good health. Well, our faith traditions
tell us that we are supposed to be about healing each other, and today
that means helping each other figure out how to access the miracles of
modern medicine. It means a community response, well thought out, and
with everybody participating and everybody benefiting. A response chosen
by the people, together.
But this initiative turns
our state constitution into a roadblock, a barrier to options we might
like to consider, in these next few years, while we are working, together,
to get it right. Let's decide what YES looks like, before we let special
interests start putting NO in cement.
Give us, all of us, more
time, to get it right. Vote AGAINST this initiative."
|
Carolyn Redmore,
President, Church Women United in Tucson, Tucson
|
Jane Rohwer,
Finance Chairperson, Church Women United in Tucson, Tucson
|
|
Paid
for by "Church Women United in Tucson"
|
"As candidates for Arizona
Green Party, we urge a NO vote.
The people who govern us
have diddled around, scared by lobbyists and special interests, and have
given us a two tiered healthcare system: a decent one for lawmakers,
and for folks for whom money is no concern, and a third-world healthcare
system for the rest of us. In measure after measure of healthcare decency,
we score, not first in the world, but sixteenth, or twenty-third, or
eighth, or seventy-ninth. Long waits in other countries, for nonemergency
care? Long waits here, if you've looked lately. And then the insurance,
that you've paid into all your life, raises rates, raises co-pays, or
doesn't pay at all.
The solution has to be an
American one, because this is who we are. But to find the solution, we
have to get past the myths, and look at the reality. We need to understand
why our healthcare system is the most expensive in the world, yet delivers
so much less than it should. Did you know that a full third of the money
spent on healthcare in this country goes to bureaucratic "management," ie,
the insurance industry? Did you know that our much-touted pharmaceutical
industry spends more on advertising than on research? There are some
big mistakes being made here, and nobody is willing to look it over,
and rein it in.
"Choice" is not
simply about individuals choosing between lousy options-- it is about
voters choosing to create better options to choose from. You can learn
more about this measure, and about other initiatives, on the AzGP website,
at www.azgp.org
Meanwhile, vote NO. "
|
Claudia Ellquist,
Green Party Candidate for Pima County Attorney, Tucson
|
Kent Solberg,
Green Party Candidate for the Arizona House, Legislative District
27, Tucson
|
|
Paid
for by "Elect Ellquist"
|
ARGUMENT
AGAINST C-15-2008 THE MEDICAL CHOICE FOR ARIZONA, OR FREEDOM TO CHOOSE
ACT
The Arizona Chapter of the
American Academy of Pediatrics opposes PROP 101 "The
Medical
Choice for Arizona
or Freedom to Choose Act.
As pediatricians, we think
that Arizona residents should be able to choose among a wide variety
of health care reform proposals to decrease the number of Arizona children
who lack health insurance. There are currently over one million Arizona
residents who are uninsured, including over 250,000 children. Lack of
health insurance hurts all of us by increasing the use of emergency departments,
decreasing preventive care services which increase the risk of communicable
disease, and cost shifting of the expenses incurred by the uninsured
on the insured population.
This measure would prevent
us from adopting many of the proposed health care reform measures currently
under consideration at both the local and national level to address the
increasing numbers of uninsured. We need to have every potential option
for health care reform available for Arizona's children and their families.
We also do not want to see loopholes created in our Arizona constitution
which would allow insurance companies to deny health insurance coverage
for any reason.
We must defeat this measure
so that all options for increasing insurance coverage for Arizona children
are available. Therefore, Arizona's pediatricians urge you to vote no
on PROP 101, the Medical Choice for Arizona or
Freedom
to Choose Act.
|
Keith Dveirin,
MD, FAAP, Immediate Past President, Arizona Chapter, American Academy
of Pediatrics, Phoenix
|
Gretchen Hull,
MD, FAAP, Secretary, Arizona Chapter, American Academy of Pediatrics,
Phoenix
|
|
Paid
for by "Arizona Chapter, American Academy of Pediatrics"
|
WESTMARC
urges a NO VOTE on Proposition
101!
WESTMARC is a regional coalition
of business, government, and education that advocates for good public
policy. As a partnership between business and government, it is paramount
that we thoroughly consider public policy issues and work collaboratively
toward public policy that is good for our West Valley region and our
state.
WESTMARC
has thoroughly reviewed Proposition
101 and
does not believe that the Medical Choice for Arizona Initiative will
be beneficial to our region and state.
WESTMARC believes that:
-
the language of the
Initiative is ambiguous and unclear and accordingly raises far more
questions than it answers;
-
because of the ambiguity
and lack of clarity the Initiative will likely invite costly and lengthy
litigation;
-
since this is a Constitutional
change, the unintended consequences will haunt Arizonans forever;
-
out-of-state interests
continually seek to implement philosophical and policy changes through
Arizona's relatively easy initiative process as a precedent for those
changes elsewhere in the country; this Initiative has an overwhelming
portion of its funding from out-of-state; and
-
there doesn't appear
to be any need for the Initiative because we can't determine there's
any problem the Initiative is trying to fix.
WESTMARC
believes in our freedoms and appreciates our choices in a free market.
However a change of this potential magnitude without the benefit of
clear and open public discussion is not the way we should develop and
or change public policy.
We encourage
you to join WESTMARC in opposing the Medical Choice for Arizona Initiative
and urge you to vote NO on Proposition
101!
|
Ray L. Jones,
Chairman, WESTMARC, Peoria
|
Jack W. Lunsford,
President & CEO, WESTMARC, Peoria
|
|
Paid
for by "WESTMARC"
|
This measure is not about
guaranteeing choice. It's about making sure Arizonans are required to
channel our health care dollars into the pockets of big insurance companies
and the for-profit health care industry. Make no mistake, the backers
of this measure view health care like any other business that must generate
increasing revenues for its shareholders. Private insurers spend billions
of dollars a year on marketing and advertising. Their top executives
take home multi-million dollar salaries. They deliver handsome profits
to their shareholders. And they employ staff whose primary job is to
deny claims or otherwise make it difficult for patients to access the
coverage for which they pay their monthly premiums. As a result, administrative
costs in the private health insurance industry are four to ten times
as high as those of government backed health care plans like Medicare.
If this initiative were to
pass, Arizonans would be barred from ever choosing a government backed
universal health care plan that would make sure every Arizonan was covered,
regardless of pre-existing conditions or ability to pay. Proposition
101 is protectionism for the health care industry. They want to be protected
from competition so that they can continue to increase profits on the
backs of hard-working Arizonans. We think the health care industry is
already making plenty of money. We urge voters to reject this deceptively
named measure and Vote No on Proposition 101.
The Arizona Advocacy Network
promotes social, economic, racial and environmental justice by educating
voters on ballot measures and by working to achieve quality, affordable
health care for all.
|
Michael J.
Valder, President, Arizona Advocacy Network, Phoenix
|
Eric Ehst,
Treasurer, Arizona Advocacy Network, Phoenix
|
|
Paid
for by "Arizona Advocacy Network"
|
Don't be fooled by the so-called
Freedom of Choice in Healthcare Act. This is not about the freedom of
consumers to "choose" their own healthcare but is designed
to guarantee insurance companies and doctors the freedom to continue
making windfall profits at our expense. Passage of Prop 101 will constitutionally
prevent the Legislature or the voters from instituting healthcare solutions
that limit costs or guarantee treatment.
If you're happy with the
state of our current healthcare system, if you think you are getting
good service at fair prices, if you think that having thousands of uninsured
children is acceptable, if you think that denial of coverage for serious
medical conditions is fair, this is the proposition for you. This measure
ensures the continuation of the status quo, with ever increasing prices
and ever decreasing quality of service.
If you think we deserve better,
don't vote for this "Insurance Company Protection Act." Join
with Arizona NOW to vote NO on Prop 101.
|
Eric Ehst,
Policy Coordinator (President), Arizona National Organization for
Women, Phoenix
|
Marge Mead,
Legislative Coordinator, Vice President, Arizona National Organization
for Women, Sun City
|
|
Paid
for by "Arizona National Organization for Women"
|
I oppose PROP 101' the "Medical
Choice" Initiative, because it Could restrict the ability of the
state to reasonably limit abortion and other medical services in appropriate
circumstances. The initiative says, "No law shall interfere with
a person's or an entity's right to pay directly for lawful medical services." Abortion
is a lawful medical service, yet the state currently has the ability
to limit it in certain circumstances. Under this initiative, the state
Could lose that ability. That means that the state could not, for example,
as it has in the past, prohibit insurance coverage for abortion in certain
reasonable situations. Currently, the state forbids the use of taxpayer
money for abortions for minors in foster care and, in many cases, for
those receiving welfare benefits (AHCCCS). Even beyond the abortion issue,
this initative has red flags. Consider what an "entity" might
be. An insurance company? A school district? A community center? A state
agency? This vague, wide-open, unrestricted initiative has no exclusions
and no boundaries. It needs a lot more scrutiny than it has received.
Please vote NO on PROP 101.
|
Charlotte Reed,
President, Arizona Republican Assembly, Phoenix
|
Gene Reed,
1st Vice President, Arizona Republican Assembly, Phoenix
|
|
Paid
for by "Arizona Republican Assembly"
|
|
|
|
PROPOSED
AMENDMENT TO THE CONSTITUTION
BY
THE INITIATIVE RELATING TO HEALTH CARE
|
|
PROPOSING
AN AMENDMENT TO THE CONSTITUTION OF ARIZONA; AMENDING ARTICLE II OF
THE ARIZONA CONSTITUTION BY ADDING SECTION 36 OF ARTICLE II; RELATING
TO FREEDOM OF CHOICE IN HEALTH CARE.
|
|
PROHIBITS
LAWS THAT: RESTRICT PERSON'S CHOICE OF PRIVATE HEALTH CARE SYSTEMS
OR PRIVATE PLANS; INTERFERE WITH PERSON'S OR ENTITY'S RIGHT TO PAY
DIRECTLY FOR LAWFUL MEDICAL SERVICES; IMPOSE A PENALTY OR FINE FOR
CHOOSING TO OBTAIN OR DECLINE HEALTH CARE COVERAGE OR FOR PARTICIPATION
IN ANY HEALTH CARE SYSTEM OR PLAN.
|
|
|
|
|
A "yes" vote
shall have the effect of prohibiting laws that restrict a person's
choice of private health care systems or private plans, interfere with
a person or an entity's right to pay for lawful medical services, and
impose a penalty or fine for choosing to obtain or decline health care
coverage or for participation in any health care system or plan.
|
YES
|
|
A "no" vote
shall have the effect of retaining the current law regarding a person
or entity's health care choices.
|
NO
|
The Ballot Format displayed in
HTML reflects only the text of the Ballot Proposition and does not
reflect how it will appear on the General Election Ballot.
Spelling, grammar, and punctuation were reproduced as submitted in the "for" and "against" arguments.
JANICE
K. BREWER
Arizona Secretary of State
|
|
© September
2008
|
|